Print Email Facebook Twitter A logical critique of the expert position in design research: beyond expert justification of design methods and towards empirical validation Title A logical critique of the expert position in design research: beyond expert justification of design methods and towards empirical validation Author Vermaas, P.E. (TU Delft Ethics & Philosophy of Technology) Date 2016 Abstract This paper gives a general and logical analysis of the expert position in design research bywhich methods for innovative design can be derived from expert design practices. It firstgives a framework for characterising accounts of design by the way in which they defineand relate general, descriptive and prescribed types of design practices. Second, it analyseswith this framework the expert position's conservatism of prescribing existing expert designpractices to non-expert designers. Third, it argues that the expert status of expert designersdoes not provide suficient justification for prescribing expert design practices to non-expert designers; it is shown that this justification needs support by empirical testing.Fourth, it discusses validation of designmethods for presenting an approach to this testing.One consequence of the need to empirically test the expert position is that its prescriptionhas to be formulated in more detail. Another consequence is that it undermines the expertposition since expert design practices are not anymore certain sources for deriving designmethods with. Yet it also opens the expert position to other sources for developing designmethods for innovation, such as the practices of contemporary designers and the insightsof design researchers. Subject design researchexpert designdesign methodsvalidation To reference this document use: http://resolver.tudelft.nl/uuid:0e154950-9900-4a4e-be8d-12baab900a0a DOI https://doi.org/10.1017/dsj.2016.6 ISSN 2053-4701 Source Design Science: An international journal, 2, 1-23 Part of collection Institutional Repository Document type journal article Rights © 2016 P.E. Vermaas Files PDF 2016_Design_Science_exper ... lished.pdf 772.57 KB Close viewer /islandora/object/uuid:0e154950-9900-4a4e-be8d-12baab900a0a/datastream/OBJ/view