The Dialogue of the City

The Dialogue of the City: Implementing a productive Citizen Participation Method for Urban Node Development, in Delft the Netherlands

van Bergen, Anne (TU Delft Architecture and the Built Environment; TU Delft Applied Sciences)

Dabrowski, M.M. (mentor)
van Dorst, M.J. (graduation committee)
van der Sanden, M.C.A. (mentor)
Wehrmann, C. (graduation committee)

Delft University of Technology

Applied Sciences | Science Education and Communication

2019-10-18

Participatory processes have become unexceptional in Dutch planning. Due to the communicative turn in urban planning, collaborative planning moved up on the local and national government agenda: in 2021 the new environmental act will come into place, which firmly encourages participation in an early stage of the process. Within those participatory processes, face-to-face contact is currently indisputably the most used method. Practitioners believe that increasing the moments of contact is the best strategy to quickly reach consensus, even though only half of the participating citizens say that it indeed contributes to mutual trust and understanding. And although citizen participation is not something new in the Netherlands, its effectiveness leaves much to be desired. Despite the increase of attention for citizen engagement, the actual interaction between citizen and urban planner has not been studied extensively. Why and how to arrange a productive interaction with citizens is not clearly stated in literature nor known from practice. This leaves spatial planners with a large uncertainty on how to employ dialogue in daily practice. Therefore, the central question in this double degree thesis revolves around the face-to-face interaction between urban planners and citizens. It researches the gap between the ideal but rather theoretical concept of dialogue with citizens and the unruly reality of practice. It focuses on how the urban planner should manage the dilemmas of dialogue and how he/she could facilitate this interaction in an effective way, in order to let the process contribute to something constructive. Dialogical principles were taken as starting point and experts were consulted about dialogue in participation’s functioning in practice. The generic framework which results from this, is applied in the case of the redevelopment of Delft Campus station. That is done by developing a game for the interaction between citizens and planner, which served as input for the spatial design which followed. By developing and reflecting on these three different products - the general framework, the game and the spatial design - the thesis provides practitioners with an advice how to deal with the complex conversations which they have to deal with today.

citizen participation
collaborative planning
dialogue
urban planner-citizen interaction
communication design
Delft Zuid
Design-based research

http://resolver.tudelft.nl/uuid:402474ce-d796-42fc-8e9f-96cf508f1b4b

51.990730, 4.364604

This master thesis is a joint graduation project of MSc Architecture, Urbanism and the Building Sciences (Urbanism track) and MSc Science Education and Communication (Science Communication track), both at the Delft University of Technology.

Student theses

master thesis

© 2019 Anne van Bergen