Preference-Based Design in Architecture

Preference-Based Design in Architecture

Binnekamp, R.

Barzilai, J. (promotor)

Architecture

Real Estate & Housing

2010-05-07

Architectural design is a complex process as a result of two prominent characteristics of choice making: 1) multiple designs can fit into one intended purpose, which raises the question: how to choose the design that fits best, and 2) a multitude of decision makers have an interest in the design process, which is the problem of group choice making. The application of the field of decision theory is aimed at finding tools, methodologies and software to help people, or groups of people, make better choices. The scientific foundation of selection (choice) is preference measurement. The correctness of a decision analysis methodology is determined by the correctness of the scales used for measuring preference. All classical models of the theory of measurement generate scales to which the operations of addition and multiplication are not applicable. A new methodology called Preference Function Modeling (PFM) offers a correct model for the measurement of preference and for the selection of the most preferred alternative. In its current form however, PFM is an evaluation methodology, helping decision makers to choose the most preferred design alternative from a set of already existing alternatives. In the domain of architecture a design methodology is needed, where the design alternatives are not known a priori. The Preference-Based Design procedure proposed in this thesis offers a design methodology in which the feasibility of considered alternatives is established using the concept from the Open Design Linear Programming (LP) technique of defining an alternative as a combination of decision variable values within negotiable constraints. The PFM algorithm is used to rank the feasible design alternatives on preference. The relevance of this thesis is two-fold: 1. The quality of decisions is improved, since only feasible designs are taken into consideration. 2. The acceptance of decisions is improved, since all decision makers can see that their interests are genuinely taken into account.

multi-criteria decision making
preference measurement
design methodology
architecture

http://resolver.tudelft.nl/uuid:4ee0e3c4-8af6-4109-9cc1-8ade2de20e7f

IOS Press

9781607505501

Institutional Repository

doctoral thesis

(c) 2010 Binnekamp, R.