A Review of Value-Conflicts in Cybersecurity

A Review of Value-Conflicts in Cybersecurity: An assessment based on quantitative and qualitative literature analysis

Christen, Markus (University of Zürich)
Gordijn, Bert (Dublin City University)
Weber, Karsten (Brandenburg University of Technology Cottbus)
van de Poel, I.R. (TU Delft Values Technology and Innovation)
Yaghmaei, E. (TU Delft Ethics & Philosophy of Technology)

Values Technology and Innovation

2017

Cybersecurity is of capital importance in a world where economic and social processes increasingly rely on digital technology. Although the primary ethical motivation of cybersecurity is prevention of informational or physical harm, its enforcement can also entail conflicts with other moral values. This contribution provides an outline of value conflicts in cybersecurity based on a quantitative literature analysis and qualitative case studies. The aim is to demonstrate that the security-privacydichotomy—that still seems to dominate the ethics discourse based on our bibliometric analysis—is insufficient when discussing the ethical challenges of cybersecurity. Furthermore, we want to sketch how the notion of contextual integrity could help to better understand and mitigate such value conflicts.

Cybersecurity
Moral Values
Value Conflicts
Privacy
Contextual Integrity

http://resolver.tudelft.nl/uuid:50e17171-5d6e-4769-95ae-23809855fb6b

Orbit, An Online Journal for Responsible Research and Innovation in ICT, 1 (1), 1-19

Institutional Repository

journal article

© 2017 Markus Christen, Bert Gordijn, Karsten Weber, I.R. van de Poel, E. Yaghmaei