The use of systematic and heuristic methods in the basic design cycle: A comparative survey of students' method usage

The use of systematic and heuristic methods in the basic design cycle: A comparative survey of students' method usage

Person, F.E.O.K.
Daalhuizen, J.J.
Gattol, V.

Industrial Design Engineering

Product Innovatie Management

2013-09-05

In the present paper, we study the reported use of systematic and heuristic methods for 304 students enrolled in a master-level course on design theory and methodology. What to teach design and engineering students about methods is an important topic for discussion. One reason for this is that the experiences of design educators when using methods in their teaching do not always sit well with how methods are portrayed in the literature. Based on self-reports of the students, we study the use of systematic and heuristic methods for the five activities in the basic design cycle: (1) analysis, (2) synthesis, (3) simulation, (4) evaluation, and (5) decision-making. The results of our study suggest that systematic and heuristic methods fulfil different roles for the students when designing. The students reported to use heuristic methods significantly more for synthesis, while they reported to use systematic methods significantly more for evaluation and decision making. In understanding the potential origin of these use practices, we call for more in-depth studies on method usage in design, for instance related to the role of preference and knowledge on systematic and heuristic methods usage.

method teaching
heuristic methods
systematic methods
EPDE

http://resolver.tudelft.nl/uuid:7ef391f1-b83b-4991-808d-308856a980fb

E&PDE 2013: International Conference on Engineering and Product Design Education, Dublin, Ireland, 5-6 September 2013

Institutional Repository

conference paper

(c) 2013 The Author(s)