The Missing Stock: Exploring Concrete Use in Trondheim’s Residential Building Foundations

The Missing Stock: Exploring Concrete Use in Trondheim’s Residential Building Foundations

Ilgemann, Pablo (TU Delft Technology, Policy and Management)

Fishman, Tomer (mentor)
Sprecher, B. (mentor)
Müller, Daniel B. (mentor)
Ljunge, Jonna (mentor)

Delft University of Technology
Universiteit Leiden

Industrial Ecology

2023-03-04

Concrete is one of the most widely used materials in residential building construction. It contributes about 4% to 7% of global greenhouse gas emissions annually. Thus, better understanding the material stocks and flows of concrete can support efforts to better manage this resource and its use. Concrete is especially popular for the construction of building foundations. Previous research has shown that foundations can account for 25% to 60% of residential housing mass. Despite this, no in-depth analysis of material requirements of foundations has been conducted. Foundation design depends on the housing type and soil type. Considering foundations’ substantial share of building mass, I analyze them in this thesis in the form of a case study of residential housing built in Trondheim between 2010 and 2020. To account for all emissions from cradle-to-construction site I also compare the concrete production emissions to the last-leg transport emissions. The residential building foundations’ material requirements were estimated with a model I specifically developed for this thesis. 507 000 tonnes of concrete were used from 2010 to 2020 to build residential building foundations in Trondheim. The results show that the concrete production emissions represent 99% and the last-leg transport emissions 1% of the total cradle-to-construction site emissions. The average material intensity coefficient across all buildings in Trondheim is 402 kg of concrete in the foundation per one m2 useful floor area. I disaggregated the buildings into five types: single family house, semi-detached house, rowhouse, apartment building, assisted & communal living. When disaggregated, the building types’ material intensities vary, on average, 8% around 402 kg/m2 useful floor area. The largest difference being 20% below the mean. As a result, there are no substantial differences of material requirements per m2 useful floor area between different building types. However, building on peat and bog soils increases the material requirements by 80% compared to all other soil types found in Trondheim. This is due to the low bearing capacity of peat and bog soils. Trondheim currently plans its residential zoning until 2034. 5% of the planned zones are located on peat and bog. A rough estimate suggests that up to 380 000 tonnes of carbon could be stored in the affected peat and bog areas, which could be released as construction on this land begins. Together with the 80% increased material requirements of foundations on peat and bog, this can cause a lot of emissions. As a result, my short-term recommendation is that these areas are either preserved as nature reserves or only light structures that do not need a foundation are constructed. In the long-term I recommend that new zoning types for city planning are developed that take soil types into account. Lastly, the effects of soil types should be taken into account in future studies of the material stock in residential housing. Feel free to contact the author for more information and the supporting information.

http://resolver.tudelft.nl/uuid:e335e0ac-0cc3-4b40-a3fb-582ce38eb6a5

Student theses

master thesis

© 2023 Pablo Ilgemann