Applying Value Sensitive Design (VSD) to Wind Turbines and Wind Parks: An Exploration

Applying Value Sensitive Design (VSD) to Wind Turbines and Wind Parks: An Exploration

Oosterlaken, E.T. (TU Delft Values Technology and Innovation)

Values Technology and Innovation

2015

Community acceptance still remains a challenge for wind energy projects. The most popular explanation for local opposition, the Not in My Backyard effect, has received fierce criticism in the past decade. Critics argue that opposition is not merely a matter of selfishness or ignorance, but that moral, ecological and aesthetic values play an important role. In order to better take such values into account, a more bottom-up, participatory decision process is usually proposed. Research on this topic focusses on either stakeholder motivations/attitudes, or their behavior during project implementation. This paper proposes a third research focus, namely the ‘objects’ which elicit certain behavioral responses and attitudes—the wind turbine and parks. More concretely, this paper explores Value Sensitive Design (VSD) as way to arrive at wind turbines and parks that better embed or reflect key values. After a critical discussion of the notion of acceptance versus acceptability and support, the paper discusses existing literature on ecology and aesthetics in relation to wind turbine/park design, which could serve as ‘building blocks’ of a more integral VSD approach of the topic. It also discusses the challenge of demarcating wind park projects as VSD projects. A further challenge is that VSD has been applied mainly at the level of technical artifacts, whereas wind parks can best be conceptualized as socio-technical system. This new application would therefore expand the current practice of VSD, and may as a consequence also lead to interesting new insights for the VSD community. The paper concludes that such an outcome-oriented approach of wind turbines and park is worth exploring further, as a supplement to rather than a replacement of the process-oriented approach that is promoted by the current literature on community acceptance of wind parks.

Aesthetics
Ecology
Justice
Community acceptance
Social acceptance

http://resolver.tudelft.nl/uuid:fd13c458-cd43-41ec-b75d-11cd4515f4c8

https://doi.org/10.1007/s11948-014-9536-x

1471-5546

Science & Engineering Ethics, 2015 (21)

Institutional Repository

journal article

© 2015 E.T. Oosterlaken